Student Voices - Life Inside the System
The Prépa Crucible: Two Years That Define a Lifetime
"I remember the first day perfectly," says Aminata Diallo, her voice carrying a mix of pride and residual exhaustion. "I walked into Lycée Henri-IV thinking I was smart. Within a week, I realized I had never truly learned how to work." Now a third-year student at École Polytechnique, Aminata's journey through the French elite education system illuminates both its transformative power and its human cost.
#### A Day in Prépa Life
5:45 AM: Aminata's alarm rings in her tiny studio near the lycée. Many prépa students live in cramped quarters, prioritizing proximity to school over comfort.
6:30 AM: Breakfast while reviewing math problems. "You learn to optimize every minute," she explains.
8:00 AM - 12:00 PM: Four hours of mathematics. Not the mathematics of high school—this is analysis, algebra, and geometry at a level that would challenge university students elsewhere.
1:00 PM - 5:00 PM: Physics and chemistry, with barely a break for lunch.
5:30 PM - 7:00 PM: Weekly "colle"—oral interrogation where two or three students face a professor at the blackboard. "It's terrifying at first," Aminata recalls. "You're solving problems in real-time while explaining your reasoning. But it teaches you to think under pressure."
7:30 PM - 11:00 PM: Homework, problem sets, reading. The official program suggests 4-5 hours of personal work daily. Reality often demands more.
11:30 PM: Brief call home to Marseille. "My parents, first-generation immigrants from Senegal, didn't understand the system. They just knew their daughter was exhausted but determined."
Weekends offer little respite—Saturday morning classes, Sunday devoted to catching up and preparing for the week ahead.
#### The Psychological Toll and Support Systems
Dr. Marie-Claire Beaumont, psychologist at a Parisian prépa, sees hundreds of students annually. "The pressure can be overwhelming. These young people, accustomed to being the best, suddenly find themselves average or below. It's an identity crisis."
The statistics are sobering: - 40% of prépa students report anxiety disorders - 15% experience depression requiring treatment - 60% report chronic sleep deprivation
Yet the system has evolved. "Twenty years ago, suffering was seen as character-building," notes Dr. Beaumont. "Now we recognize that supporting student well-being improves performance."
Modern support systems include: - On-site psychological services - Peer mentoring programs - Stress management workshops - More humane teaching approaches (though intensity remains)
"My math teacher saved me," reflects Jin Wei, an international student from Shanghai now at Mines ParisTech. "When I was ready to quit, he spent hours helping me adapt to French mathematical reasoning. It wasn't just about solving problems—it was learning to think in a completely different way."
Inside the Grandes Écoles: After the Selection
École Polytechnique: Where Tradition Meets Innovation
Lieutenant Sophie Mercier stands at attention in the courtyard of École Polytechnique, her blue uniform immaculate. The military tradition here isn't mere ceremony—it shapes daily life and creates unique bonds.
"The first year is intense," Sophie explains. "Military training, academics, learning to balance freedom with responsibility." Polytechnique students remain military officers during their studies, receiving a salary but also obligations.
The academic program blends: - Advanced theoretical courses (mathematics, physics, computer science) - Applied projects with real-world impact - Humanities seminars with leading intellectuals - Research internships in world-class laboratories
"What surprised me most was the intellectual freedom," says Ahmed Benali, from a modest background in Lyon's suburbs. "In prépa, there's one way to solve problems. Here, professors encourage us to challenge established methods."
The social dynamics are complex. "There's definitely an elite bubble," Ahmed admits. "But there's also genuine solidarity. When you've survived the same selection process, barriers break down."
International exposure is mandatory. Sophie spent six months at MIT, Ahmed at Imperial College London. "It opened my eyes," Sophie reflects. "French mathematical training is exceptional, but we sometimes lack the entrepreneurial mindset I saw in America."
HEC: Business School with French Characteristics
The atmosphere at HEC's Jouy-en-Josas campus differs markedly from Polytechnique's military precision. Here, future business leaders network, compete, and collaborate in a environment that consciously mimics corporate life.
"HEC teaches you to belong," observes Clara Petit, president of the student investment club. "It's not just about finance or marketing—it's about understanding codes, building networks, projecting confidence."
The curriculum balances: - Core business disciplines - Liberal arts seminars - Entrepreneurship projects - International exchanges (often multiple) - Intensive recruiting preparation
Student associations dominate campus life. Clara's investment club manages a real portfolio. The luxury club organizes visits to LVMH headquarters. The social entrepreneurship association partners with NGOs in Africa.
"The pressure here is different from prépa," notes Marcus Schmidt, a German student attracted by HEC's international reputation. "It's not about solving equations—it's about crafting your image, building your network, positioning yourself."
Career services at HEC resemble a military operation. Mock interviews, case study preparation, networking events with alumni. "By final year, getting offers from McKinsey or Goldman Sachs feels almost anticlimactic," Clara observes. "The real question becomes: Is this what I want?"
Sciences Po: The Political Greenhouse
Sciences Po Paris occupies renovated buildings in the 7th arrondissement, its location in the heart of political Paris no accident. Here, future diplomats, journalists, and politicians learn to navigate power.
"Sciences Po is about learning to speak," explains Léa Durand, a third-year student specializing in international relations. "Not just French—though we do that too—but the language of politics, of persuasion, of nuance."
The pedagogical approach differs from other grandes écoles: - Small seminar discussions rather than large lectures - Emphasis on oral presentation and debate - Interdisciplinary approach to complex issues - Mandatory year abroad at partner institutions - Exposure to practitioners—ministers, ambassadors, journalists
"My classmates intimidated me initially," admits Moussa Keita, from a ZEP (disadvantaged area) high school who entered through Sciences Po's CEP (Priority Education Convention) program. "They'd traveled the world, spoke multiple languages, could quote obscure philosophers. But Sciences Po taught me my perspective had value too."
The CEP program, admitting students from partner high schools without traditional concours, represents one of the most ambitious diversity efforts in the grandes écoles system. "It's not charity," insists Moussa. "We work just as hard. But we bring different experiences."
Student political engagement runs high. "Every election, every protest, every international crisis—we debate endlessly," says Léa. "Sometimes it's exhausting, but it's also exhilarating to be surrounded by people who care so deeply about the world."
The Outsider's Perspective: International Students Navigate the System
Emma Thompson, from Manchester, chose to attempt the French prépa system rather than apply to Oxbridge. "My French friends thought I was insane," she laughs. "Why subject yourself to this when you have other options?"
Now at CentraleSupélec, Emma offers unique insights:
"The mathematical preparation is extraordinary. At Cambridge, my friends are brilliant, but they haven't developed the same problem-solving automatisms. However, they're more creative, more willing to challenge professors."
"The hierarchy shocked me. In Britain, we pretend class doesn't matter while it shapes everything. Here, educational pedigree is explicit. People introduce themselves by their school."
"The support network is incredible. Alumni genuinely help younger graduates. But it's also limiting—there are expected career paths, and deviation is noted."
Chen Liu, from Beijing, studying at ESSEC, adds another perspective: "Chinese education is also intense, but it's about memorization. French prépas teach you to reason. However, both systems share an obsession with ranking that can be destructive."
"What I appreciate is the intellectual culture. Business students here read philosophy, discuss politics. It's not just about making money," Chen notes, though he adds with a smile, "Though people certainly track starting salaries obsessively."
Breaking Barriers: Diversity in Elite Spaces
The grandes écoles have historically been homogeneous spaces—white, bourgeois, Parisian. This is changing, slowly and sometimes painfully.
Fatima El Amrani wears her hijab at École Centrale Lyon, one of few visibly Muslim students. "I'm often the only one who looks like me in class. It's isolating but also motivating. I'm here to prove we belong."
Her presence sparks conversations: "Some classmates had never really talked to a practicing Muslim. We've had fascinating discussions about laïcité, integration, what it means to be French."
The school has been supportive: "They arranged prayer space, halal options in the cafeteria. Small things that matter." But challenges remain: "Networking events often revolve around alcohol. Study groups meet in bars. You have to navigate constantly."
Jean-Baptiste Tran, whose parents run a Vietnamese restaurant in the 13th arrondissement, offers another perspective on class dynamics: "At HEC, some classmates spend spring break skiing in Courchevel. I'm working at my parents' restaurant. The economic gap is real."
Yet he's found allies: "There are more of us than you'd think—children of immigrants, scholarship students, provincial strivers. We form our own networks."
Mental Health and Well-being: A New Priority
The intense pressure of the system has long been acknowledged but rarely addressed. This is changing, partly due to student advocacy.
"My breakdown came in second year of prépa," shares Marie Leblanc, now at ENS. "I was studying 16 hours a day, not sleeping, surviving on coffee and anxiety. One day, I simply couldn't get out of bed."
Her story isn't unique. But unlike previous generations who suffered in silence, today's students are speaking out:
- Student associations organizing wellness weeks - Apps for meditation and stress management - Peer support groups - Campaigns to normalize seeking help
"The paradox is that the system selects for perfectionism then punishes it," observes Dr. Beaumont. "The most successful students are often those who learn to manage their perfectionism, not those who embody it."
Schools are responding: - Reduced course loads in some prépas - "Soft landing" programs for struggling students - Investment in sports facilities and cultural activities - Recognition that burnout serves no one
Love, Life, and Growing Up
Despite the pressure, or perhaps because of it, intense friendships and romances bloom in the grandes écoles.
"Prépa bonds are unique," explains Alexandre Moreau, reminiscing about his time at Louis-le-Grand. "You suffer together, succeed together. My study group from prépa—we still meet monthly, fifteen years later."
Romance in the pressure cooker has its own dynamics. "Dating someone from your prépa is intense," laughs Sarah Chen. "You study together, stress together. It either bonds you forever or explodes spectacularly."
At the grandes écoles themselves, social life becomes more balanced. "After prépa, even Polytechnique feels relaxed," notes Sophie. "There are parties, sports, cultural associations. You remember you're young."
The gender dynamics are evolving. Engineering schools, once male bastions, are actively recruiting women. "Being one of five women in a class of forty has challenges," admits Aminata. "But it's changing. And honestly, after prépa, imposter syndrome seems silly. We proved we belong."
Alternative Paths and Second Chances
Not everyone follows the traditional trajectory, and their stories are equally valuable.
Thomas Petit failed the concours twice before entering INSA Lyon through an alternative route. "The shame was crushing initially. In my prépa, success was expected." Now a successful engineer, he reflects: "The detour taught me resilience traditional students sometimes lack."
Some discover the system isn't for them. Louise Martin left ENS after one year: "I realized I'd been following others' expectations. Leaving took more courage than entering." She now runs a successful social enterprise, using her analytical skills differently.
The system is creating more bridges: - University students can attempt certain concours - Professional experience can supplement academic credentials - International degrees gain recognition - Online programs expand access
"The monopoly is breaking," observes Professor Dubois. "Slowly, but it's happening."
Looking Forward: Student Perspectives on Reform
Current students have nuanced views on reforming the system they're navigating.
"Don't destroy what works," insists Ahmed. "The intellectual rigor, the meritocracy—these have value. But expand access, recognize different excellences."
Clara agrees: "The networking advantage is real. Rather than eliminating it, create more networks. Every talented student should have access to mentorship and connections."
Moussa emphasizes representation: "Seeing professors, successful alumni who look like you matters enormously. Recruitment must diversify at all levels."
Emma brings an international perspective: "Maintain the intellectual excellence but reduce the psychological pressure. Other countries prove you can have one without the other."
As these voices reveal, life inside the grandes écoles system is complex, challenging, sometimes brutal, but also transformative. Students emerge changed—more confident, more capable, but also marked by the experience. Understanding their journeys is essential for evaluating what the system does well and what must change.
The human dimension—the dreams, struggles, friendships, and growth—reminds us that beyond policy debates and statistics, the grandes écoles shape real lives. These student voices, diverse and sometimes contradictory, paint a portrait of a system in transition, where tradition and change coexist uneasily but necessarily.
---